We tried to do this by showing our heroes (Greg and Jess) in a video talking through the organization problems (bad guys) they confront every day as they do ministry.
You'll have to read Donald Miller's book on StoryBrand. I listened to it on Audible and remember three specific places where bad guys can be found.
It's awesome for a church to focus on worship, small groups, student, children, recovery and more ministries. But, what are the bad guys that each of these confront. Maybe these would be great topics for a better church website.
The great thing about bad guys is that they make us feel the conflict. They stir in us an emotion to look for hope, an answer and even resolution. Without the bad guy, there is no need for the hero. Without sin there is no need for sacrifice. This is the gospel story. We must tell it everywhere.